AI Search Case Study ยท justinmckelvey.com

You're looking at the case study.

Before I sell anyone on getting named by Google and AI tools, I did it here first. This is the site, the numbers and the dates.

Quick Answer

In one year this site went from 13 Google clicks a month to 7,086, and from invisible in AI answers to being cited by Perplexity on 12 of the 14 buyer questions I track. On November 18, 2026, logged-out ChatGPT named me first when asked to recommend an AI consultant for a 20-person accounting firm. It's the same weekly process I run for clients in the AI Search Program. It's my own site, not a client's, and I'll say that every time.

Author: Justin McKelvey · Numbers pulled November 19, 2026

What changed, in four numbers

13 โ†’ 7,086

Google clicks a month

November 2025 vs. October 2026. Impressions went from 1,795 a month to 1.35 million. Source: Google Search Console.

2 โ†’ 12

Perplexity citations

Same buyer questions every Monday: 2 of 12 cited on October 5, 2026; 12 of 14 on November 16, and I'm named in 8 of those answers.

#1

ChatGPT's pick

November 18, 2026, logged out: "recommend an AI consultant to set up Claude for a 20-person accounting firm." ChatGPT named me first and got every price right.

716

Visits from AI tools

People who clicked through from ChatGPT, Perplexity and others in the last 90 days. About 17 a week in June; 50 to 75 a week since August. Source: Google Analytics.

Google clicks by month

Every click from Google search to justinmckelvey.com, by month. November 2026 is still in progress (4,645 clicks through the 17th), so it isn't shown.

Nov '25
Dec
Jan '26
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct

What did I actually do?

Nothing clever. The same five things, every week, for a year. This is the process the AI Search Program runs on your site.

1. Wrote down the questions buyers ask. Not "Justin McKelvey." Questions strangers type before they hire someone: "who can set up Claude for my accounting firm?", "how much does an AI consultant cost?"

2. Checked who got named, every week. The same questions through Perplexity, ChatGPT and Claude every Monday, so I could see what moved instead of guessing.

3. Wrote the page that answers each question. One clear page per question, with real prices, real numbers and a straight answer in the first lines. 199 posts and pages since January 31, 2026, each checked against the same structure standard before it goes live.

4. Fixed what was already there. Titles, missing answers, broken links, pages that said two different prices. The small fixes add up, and they're most of the weekly work.

5. Got the facts consistent everywhere. One set of prices and one bio, the same on every page and listing, so an AI tool reading three sources gets the same answer three times.

What didn't work (yet)

  • Claude: 0 of 14. The same buyer questions on Claude have cited me zero times. Every tool picks differently, which is why I report each one on its own.
  • Months 1 to 5 were flat. Under 50 clicks a month until April. If you need results in 30 days, this isn't the right kind of work.
  • Answers move around. Ask the same question twice and you can get different names. That's why I track a fixed set of questions and show the trend, not one lucky screenshot.
  • It's my site, in my field. I know this market and I write fast. Your starting point will be different, and I'll tell you where you stand on day one.

Want this for your business?

I run the same process on your site every week and show you the score. $2,000 a month, 3-month start.

FAQ

Is this a real client result?

It's my own site, justinmckelvey.com, and I say so on purpose. I don't have published client results for the AI Search Program yet. What I can show is the exact system I'd run for you, run on my own business first, with every number dated and sourced from Google Search Console, Google Analytics and weekly AI answer checks.

How long did it take?

About a year. In November 2025 the site got 13 Google clicks a month. Growth started in April 2026, passed 1,000 clicks a month in August and reached 7,086 in October 2026. AI answers moved faster once the pages existed: Perplexity went from citing the site on 2 of 12 buyer questions on October 5, 2026 to 12 of 14 on November 16.

Will I get the same results?

Nobody can promise that, and you should be wary of anyone who does. Your market, competitors and starting point are different. What you get is the same process and the same weekly score, so you can see whether it's working for you instead of taking my word for it.

Which AI tools name you, and which don't?

As of November 2026: Perplexity cites my site on 12 of the 14 buyer questions I track and names me on 8. Logged-out ChatGPT named me first for an accounting-firm question on November 18, 2026. Claude cited me on 0 of the same 14 questions. Each tool picks differently, so I report them separately. More on each: Perplexity SEO, how to rank in ChatGPT, LLM SEO.