Justin McKelvey

Justin McKelvey

Ran snowboard shops. Taught myself to code. Now I build AI that does real work.

• AI Visibility • 14 min read •

Best AI Visibility Tools in 2026: An Honest Comparison

Quick Answer: The best AI visibility tools in 2026, by use case: Profound (enterprise plans only, custom pricing) for enterprise; Peec AI (from $95/month) for agencies; Scrunch ($250/month) for mid-market teams wanting site audits included; Otterly.ai (from $29/month) for the cheapest credible start; LLMrefs ($79/month flat for 500 prompts) for best value; Semrush AI Toolkit ($99/month/domain) or Ahrefs Brand Radar (prompt tracking from $50/month on an Ahrefs plan from $129) if you're already on those platforms. Prices re-read November 18, 2026. The honest catch: every one of these is a dashboard. They tell you where you're invisible in ChatGPT and Perplexity — none of them do the content, entity, and off-site work that fixes it.

Search volume for AI visibility tools is up roughly 1,900% year over year as of July 2026, and the money followed: Profound hit a $1 billion valuation in February, Peec AI went from zero to $10M ARR in 16 months. This category is real.

Here's my angle, so you can calibrate my bias: I didn't buy any of them. I'm an AI consultant whose own site earns named Perplexity citations, and I built my own citation tracker instead. I've since evaluated the paid tools for clients, and several are genuinely good. But I care more about what happens after the dashboard shows you a zero — and that's where this comparison ends up.

What is AI visibility?

AI visibility is how often, and how favorably, AI answer engines — ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google's AI Overviews — mention, cite, or recommend your brand when people ask the questions you should own. It's the AI-era counterpart to a search ranking: instead of a position on a results page, what counts is whether you show up inside the synthesized answer at all, and whether a competitor shows up in your place. You measure it by running a fixed set of real buyer prompts through each engine on a schedule and logging mention, citation, and recommendation rates per engine — which, as of July 2026, is the entire job every tool on this list automates.

Worth separating two words people use interchangeably: visibility is the scoreboard, and answer engine optimization is the work that moves it. The tools below sell you the scoreboard.

What do AI visibility tools actually do?

All of them run the same core loop: take a list of prompts your buyers might ask ("best CRM for contractors," "top AI consultants for small business"), run them repeatedly through ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, and others, then report whether your brand was mentioned, cited, or recommended — and who beat you. The differentiators are engine coverage, prompt volume, how well they surface why you're losing, and price.

If the concept is new, start with the AI visibility pillar guide — this post assumes you know why the measurement matters.

How do the tools compare at a glance?

Tool Price (July 2026) Best for The catch
Profound $99 Starter; $399 Growth; ~$499 standard; $2K-$5K+ enterprise Enterprise brands, deep data $99 tier is ChatGPT-only; real coverage costs $399+
Peec AI $95 Starter (50 prompts); $245 Pro; $495 Advanced Agencies, multi-brand teams Prompt limits tighten fast on lower tiers
Scrunch $250 Core (125 prompts); $500 Agency Mid-market, site audits included No free trial; steep entry for solos
Otterly.ai $29 Lite (15 prompts); $189 Standard; $489 Premium Cheapest credible start 15 prompts is thin; some engines are add-ons
LLMrefs $79 flat (500 prompts, all engines) Best value, small teams Young product, small bootstrapped team
Semrush AI Toolkit $99/month per domain Existing Semrush users 25 prompts; per-domain pricing stacks up
Ahrefs Brand Radar Prompt tracking from $50; AI Visibility Index from $199; needs an Ahrefs plan (Lite $129) Existing Ahrefs users, competitor research Two separate products; the index is the pricey part

All prices verified against vendor pages and third-party pricing guides as of July 2026. This category reprices constantly — every vendor here has adjusted plans at least once in the past year — so treat the live pricing pages as the final word and treat any comparison article, including this one, as a snapshot.

Profound: the enterprise flagship

What it is: the category leader by funding and mindshare — a $96M Series C led by Lightspeed in February 2026 at a $1B valuation, roughly $155M raised total.

What's genuinely good: the data depth is unmatched. Standard tiers analyze on the order of 24,000 AI responses monthly with hundreds of unique prompts daily, plus agent-traffic analytics and citation-source breakdowns that smaller tools can't touch. If you're a brand where a 2% shift in AI share-of-voice moves real revenue, Profound is built for you, and the product feels like the ten-figure valuation.

The honest catch: the $99 Starter tracks ChatGPT only. The moment you want Perplexity or Google's AI surfaces — and you do, that's the whole point — you're at $399/month Growth, and typical enterprise deployments run $2,000-$5,000+ per month. For a small business, that's a consultant's retainer spent on a thermometer.

Correction, September 20, 2026: those tier prices are historical. Profound's pricing page no longer publishes a dollar figure of any kind. It now sells credits consumed by Agent runs, with a self-serve Agency Growth plan at 400 credits per month per client workspace and larger thresholds sold as an Enterprise package through their accounts team. The mechanism section at the bottom of this article has the detail.

One-time · $29

Find out if ChatGPT recommends you, or your competitor.

  • The 25-query worksheet that finds your money queries
  • The 4-week tracking spreadsheet: query × engine × cited?
  • The 15-action fix checklist, ranked by impact
Continue → 30-day money-back guarantee

Instant access. Your link lands on the next screen and in your email.

What are the best Profound alternatives?

Since Profound retired its $399 and $499 self-serve plans in September 2026 and moved to custom-priced Enterprise deals, the practical alternatives are Peec AI ($95 to $495 a month) for agencies and growing teams, LLMrefs ($79 a month for 500 prompts on every engine) for the most coverage per dollar, Scrunch ($250 a month) if you want page audits included, and Otterly ($29 a month) to start small. All prices read on each vendor's pricing page November 18, 2026.

  • You were on Profound Growth for multi-engine tracking: Peec Pro ($245, 150 prompts, 3 models daily) is the closest like-for-like.
  • You want more questions tracked than you can afford elsewhere: LLMrefs, 500 prompts for $79, with weekly rather than daily reports.
  • You need someone to tell you what to fix, not just a chart: Scrunch's audits, or a one-time AI visibility audit.
  • You're a large brand that liked Profound's depth: stay and take the Enterprise demo. Nothing cheaper matches its data volume.

Peec AI: the agency favorite

What it is: a Berlin-built platform that went from launch to $10M ARR in 16 months, raised $29M+, and took another $10M at a $200M valuation in June 2026. That growth rate tells you the product converts.

What's genuinely good: the cleanest UX-to-price ratio in the mid-market. Starter is $95/month for 50 prompts across three models; Pro at $245 covers 150 prompts. The multi-brand workspaces are why agencies standardized on it — managing five clients' AI visibility in one place actually works. Annual billing takes 15% off.

The honest catch: prompt limits bind faster than you'd expect. Fifty prompts sounds like a lot until you cover your services, your competitors, and your locations — then you're shopping the $245 tier. Fine for agencies billing it through; heavier for a single SMB.

What are the best Peec AI alternatives?

The best Peec AI alternatives are LLMrefs if you want more prompts for less money, Otterly if you want the cheapest start, Scrunch if you want site audits included, and the Semrush toolkit if you already pay for Semrush. Peec itself is $95 a month for 50 prompts on 3 AI models, checked daily (read on peec.ai/pricing November 18, 2026). People look for an alternative for one of three reasons: they need more prompts than 50, they want an engine Peec's 3-model limit leaves out, or they want someone to fix what the dashboard finds.

Tool Price (read Nov 18, 2026) Prompts for that price Engines Pick it over Peec when
Peec AI (baseline) $95 / $245 / $495 a month 50 / 150 / 350 Choose 3 models, daily (the one you're replacing)
LLMrefs $79 a month, one plan 500 All engines, no add-on fees; weekly reports You need volume and every engine, and weekly is often enough
Otterly.ai $29 / $189 / $489 a month 20 / 160 / 535 3 of 7 engines, daily You want to test the idea for $29 before committing
Scrunch $250 a month (Core) See plan Multiple models plus site audits You want "why am I invisible" page audits, not just tracking
Semrush AI Toolkit $99 a month per domain 25 ChatGPT, Google AI, Gemini, Perplexity You already live in Semrush
Profound Custom (enterprise only) Custom Deepest coverage You're a large brand with an enterprise budget

The per-prompt math is the quickest way to compare: Peec Starter works out to $1.90 a prompt a month, LLMrefs to about $0.16, and Otterly Lite to $1.45. Peec's real advantages are daily checks, a clean multi-brand setup for agencies, and an API from the Pro tier up.

If the reason you're leaving Peec is that the numbers aren't moving, a different dashboard won't change that. That's a fixing problem. My AI Search Audit tests the questions your buyers actually ask across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google, then hands you the ranked list of changes. Or start with the free AI visibility report.

Scrunch: the mid-market all-rounder

What it is: a monitoring platform at $250/month (Core: 125 prompts, 5 site audits, 4 AI models) with a $500 agency tier and custom enterprise pricing.

What's genuinely good: Scrunch bundles measurement with diagnosis better than most — the site audits connect "you're invisible for this prompt" to "here's what's structurally wrong with your page," which is the connection most dashboards leave you to make alone. Seven-plus engine coverage including shopping-level tracking is strong.

The honest catch: $250/month with no free trial is a hard swing for a small business, and reviewers consistently flag the entry price as the barrier. If you have a marketing team that will act on the audits weekly, it earns its keep. If the reports will pile up unread, it won't.

Otterly.ai: the affordable entry point

What it is: a bootstrapped Austrian tool and the cheapest credible way into the category — Lite is $29/month for 15 prompts across four engines with 50+ country tracking.

What's genuinely good: the price. $29/month makes the "should I even measure this?" question cheap to answer, and I respect a bootstrapped product holding its own in a category where competitors raised nine figures. Standard at $189 adds daily tracking, API, and MCP access — quietly one of the more developer-friendly options.

The honest catch: 15 prompts is thin. That's maybe five buyer questions across three engines, so you'll track your most important queries and nothing else. Google AI Mode and Gemini are paid add-ons rather than defaults. It's a starting point, not an ending point — but starting points are underrated.

Update, November 18, 2026: Otterly's pricing page now shows Lite at $29 a month for 20 prompts on 3 of its 7 AI engines, checked daily, Standard at $189 for 160 prompts, and Premium at $489 for 535. Still the cheapest way in, and a little less thin than it was.

Want the checklist version of this? The free 12-point AI Discoverability Checklist: the self-audit for whether ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI can find and cite your site.

LLMrefs: the value pick

What it is: a one-plan tool at $79/month flat — 500 prompts, 11+ engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Copilot, DeepSeek, and more), unlimited projects and team members. Founded May 2025.

What's genuinely good: the math. At $79 for 500 prompts, LLMrefs undercuts most competitors by 50-80% on a per-prompt basis, and "unlimited projects" means a consultant or small agency can run every client under one subscription. The bundled extras — crawlability checker, llms.txt generator — are the kind of practitioner tools that suggest the founder actually does this work.

The honest catch: it's young and small. Weekly (not daily) refresh cadence on reports, a shorter track record, and the single-plan simplicity cuts both ways — no enterprise tier means no enterprise depth. But for a lean team that wants real coverage without a $3,000 annual commitment, this is the one I point people at most often.

What about the Semrush and Ahrefs bolt-ons?

Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit — $99/month per domain. Tracks 25 prompts daily across ChatGPT, Google AI, Gemini, and Perplexity, inside the Semrush interface you may already pay for (Semrush One bundles it with classic SEO at $199/month). Genuinely convenient if you live in Semrush; the 25-prompt cap and per-domain pricing make it a companion, not a flagship.

Ahrefs Brand Radar — now two products, read on ahrefs.com/brand-radar November 18, 2026: Prompt Tracking from $50/month and the AI Visibility Index (578 million prompts) from $199/month, both on top of an Ahrefs plan from $129/month (Lite). The July version of this article quoted $199 per AI platform or $699 for all six; that pricing is gone. The full math, including one real monthly bill, is in Ahrefs Brand Radar vs Semrush AI Toolkit. The strength is Ahrefs' angle: you can research any brand's AI visibility, not just your own, which makes it a competitor-intelligence weapon. The weakness is that price, which puts it firmly in "already an Ahrefs shop" territory. (Ahrefs also produced the 75,000-brand study showing branded mentions correlate with AI visibility at 0.664 — they understand this space deeply.)

Which tool should you actually buy?

  • Enterprise brand, revenue tied to AI share-of-voice: Profound. It's expensive because it's the deepest.
  • Agency managing multiple clients: Peec AI, or LLMrefs if margins are tight.
  • Mid-market team that will act on findings weekly: Scrunch.
  • Small business dipping a toe: Otterly Lite at $29, or honestly, a manual audit first.
  • Lean team wanting maximum coverage per dollar: LLMrefs at $79 flat.
  • Already paying Semrush or Ahrefs: try the bolt-on before adding a vendor.

The gap none of these tools fill

Now the part the vendors put in smaller type. Every product above is a measurement tool. They will tell you, with beautiful charts, that ChatGPT recommends your competitor and not you. What they will not do is fix it — because the fix isn't in the dashboard. It's restructuring your pages into extractable answers, adding the statistics and citations that the Princeton GEO research showed lift AI visibility by 30-40%, cleaning up your entity data, and earning the off-site mentions that predict visibility three times better than backlinks. That's the AEO playbook, and it's work, not software.

I've watched businesses pay $250/month to be told they're invisible, twelve months running, while spending $0 on becoming visible. That's backwards. The dashboard should be the smallest line item in your AI visibility budget.

It's also the gap my own practice fills for small businesses and consultants: I run the measurement — starting with a free AI visibility report on what the engines currently say about you — and then do the fixing, on a monitor-and-fix loop. My credentials are the receipts: my own site earns named Perplexity citations for frameworks I coined, verified by a tracker I built myself. If you want the self-serve version, the AI discoverability checklist covers the same audit, and this kind of work often rides along with broader AI automation for a small business.

How does AI visibility tracking work?

AI visibility tracking means asking ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google's AI the same set of buyer questions on a schedule and recording whether your business is named, where it appears in the answer, and which pages it links. Every tool above does that. The differences are how many questions (prompts) you get, which AI tools are included, and how often they check: daily on Peec and Otterly, weekly reports on LLMrefs.

Three things make tracking worth the money. Use the questions buyers really ask, with your city, industry and company size in them, not just your brand name. Track enough of them: answers change from run to run, so a trend across 50 questions tells you more than any single answer. Otterly's own guidance is 50 to 100 prompts per topic. Check the pages it cites: when a competitor gets named, the linked page shows you what to fix. When I ran two law-firm questions through ChatGPT, the answers came from Google Business Profile and Avvo listings, which no website change would have fixed (the full test).

Can you skip the tools entirely?

For a while, yes. An hour a month of manual prompt-testing gives you 80% of the signal a $250 dashboard gives you, and developers can automate the whole loop on the Perplexity API for roughly a penny per query — I show exactly how in the brand-mention tracking guide. Buy a tool when the manual habit is solid, the fixes are underway, and the monitoring time costs more than the subscription. Not before.

The tools are good. The category is real. Just remember which part of the job they do — and budget for the other part, because that's the part that shows up in revenue.

How AI visibility pricing actually works: the prompt is the unit, and the engine is the upsell

Every plan on this page is sold as a monthly price, and almost none of them are really priced that way. Two mechanisms decide what you actually pay, and neither one leads the pricing page.

The unit is a prompt, not a seat or a site. A prompt is one question, tracked on a schedule. Otterly's pricing page, read September 20, 2026, sells Lite at $29 a month for 15 search prompts, Standard at $189 for 100, and Premium at $489 for 400 — $25, $160 and $422 on annual billing. LLMrefs sells one plan at $79 a month for 500 prompts and 50 keywords. That is the whole comparison: at Otterly's Premium price you are tracking 400 questions; at LLMrefs' single price you are tracking 500 for a sixth of the money. Unlimited team members does not help you here. Fifteen prompts covers one product's buying questions, and nothing else.

The engines you care about are frequently the add-on. Otterly's Lite tier tracks ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot, and lists Claude, Google AI Mode and Gemini as extras. So a $29 plan does not answer "does Claude recommend me" at any price until you buy the add-on. LLMrefs states the opposite on the same day's read: all AI search engines, no additional fees.

And Profound has stopped printing a price at all. As of the September 20, 2026 read, tryprofound.com/pricing publishes no dollar figure — it is a credit model where credits are burned each time an Agent runs, with the self-serve Agency Growth plan at 400 credits per month per client workspace and anything above that routed to an Enterprise package through their accounts team. The only button on the page is Get a Demo. Treat any "Profound starts at $X" number you read anywhere, including the July 2026 figures earlier in this article, as historical.

Update, November 18, 2026: Profound's pricing FAQ (updated November 16) now says it retired its Starter and Growth plans for brands in September 2026, that the $399 and $499 prices are no longer available to new subscribers, and that it sells Enterprise plans with custom pricing through a demo. Otterly's prompt counts also moved: 20 on Lite, 160 on Standard, 535 on Premium, at the same $29, $189 and $489.

Free Resource Justin McKelvey

What does AI say about your business?

I'll run your domain through the citation checker I use on client work: where AI engines mention you, and the 3 fixes that matter most.

Get my free visibility report arrow_forward

Frequently Asked Questions

What is AI visibility?
AI visibility is how often, and how favorably, AI answer engines — ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google's AI Overviews — mention, cite, or recommend your brand when people ask the questions you should own. It is the AI-era counterpart to a search ranking: instead of a position on a results page, what counts is whether you appear inside the synthesized answer at all, and whether a competitor appears in your place. It is measured by running a fixed set of real buyer prompts through each engine on a schedule and logging mention, citation, and recommendation rates per engine — an hour a month by hand, or automated by the tools compared here, which as of July 2026 run $29 to $2,000+ per month.
What is the best AI visibility tool in 2026?
It depends on size and budget. As of November 18, 2026: Profound (enterprise plans only, custom pricing, since it retired its Starter and Growth plans in September 2026) leads for enterprise; Peec AI (from $95/month) is the agency favorite; Otterly.ai (from $29/month) is the cheapest credible entry point; LLMrefs ($79/month flat, 500 prompts) is the best value for small teams. No tool fixes visibility — they all just measure it.
How much do AI visibility tools cost?
As of November 18, 2026, entry points range from $29/month (Otterly Lite, 20 prompts) to $495/month (Peec AI Advanced, 350 prompts); Profound now sells only custom-priced enterprise plans. Mid-market options cluster around $79-$250/month. The Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit is $99/month per domain; Ahrefs Brand Radar prompt tracking starts at $50/month on top of an Ahrefs plan (Lite $129/month), and its AI Visibility Index starts at $199/month.
Do AI visibility tools actually improve your AI visibility?
No — they measure it. Every tool in this category tracks whether ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI mention or cite your brand across a set of prompts. Improving those numbers still requires content restructuring, entity cleanup, schema, and off-site mentions. Budget for the fixing, not just the dashboard, or you're paying monthly to watch a flat line.
Is there a free way to track AI visibility?
Yes. Run 10-20 real buyer prompts through ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini monthly and log whether you're mentioned, cited, or recommended — it takes about an hour. Developers can automate this with the Perplexity API for roughly a penny per query. That manual baseline is also the best way to know whether a paid tool is worth it for you.
What's the difference between Profound and Peec AI?
Scale and audience. Profound is the enterprise flagship — $96M Series C at a $1B valuation in February 2026, deep prompt volumes, agent analytics, priced accordingly (its $399 and $499 self-serve plans were retired in September 2026; it now sells custom enterprise plans only). Peec AI is built for agencies and mid-size teams: cleaner pricing from $95/month, multi-brand workspaces, and a $10M ARR trajectory 16 months post-launch.
Which AI visibility tool tracks Claude and Gemini without an add-on fee?
LLMrefs, as of the September 20, 2026 read of its pricing page: one plan at $79/month covering 500 prompts, 50 keywords, and all AI search engines with no additional per-engine fees. Otterly is the common alternative at $29/month, but its Lite tier tracks ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot, and lists Claude, Google AI Mode and Gemini as paid add-ons — so the $29 price does not answer a Claude question until you buy the extra. Profound no longer publishes a price at all; it sells credits consumed by Agent runs, with a self-serve Agency Growth plan at 400 credits per month per client workspace and anything larger sold as an Enterprise package.
What is the best Peec AI alternative?
LLMrefs for most small teams: $79 a month for 500 prompts across all AI engines with no add-on fees, against Peec's $95 for 50 prompts on 3 models (both read November 18, 2026). Otterly is the cheapest start at $29 for 20 prompts, Scrunch ($250) adds page audits, and the Semrush AI Toolkit ($99 per domain) makes sense if you already use Semrush. Peec is still the better pick for agencies that need daily checks across several client brands.
Should a small business pay for an AI visibility tool?
Usually not first. A small business gets more from one manual audit plus a quarter of actual fixes — answer blocks, schema, directory consistency, off-site mentions — than from a $250/month dashboard confirming it's invisible. Start with a free audit or a cheap tracker ($29-$79/month), spend the savings on fixing, then upgrade tooling when there's something to monitor.

More on AI Visibility

Perplexity SEO (2026): How I Went From 2 to 12 Cited Answers in 6 Weeks

Perplexity SEO is getting Perplexity to cite your page and name you when buyers ask who to hire. I track the same 14 buyer questions every Monday. On October 5, Perplexity cited my site on 2 of 12. On November 16 it was 12 of 14, and it named me on 8. Here's exactly what changed, and why Claude still cites me on zero.

4 min

Ahrefs Brand Radar vs Semrush AI Toolkit (2026): Prices and One Real Bill

Ahrefs Brand Radar now starts at $50 a month for prompt tracking ($199 for its 578-million-prompt index), and Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit is $99 a month for 25 prompts. Tracking the same 50 buyer questions on ChatGPT and Google's AI Overviews costs about $60 on Ahrefs, $159 on Semrush, $95 on Peec and $79 on LLMrefs.

4 min

How to Rank in Google AI Overviews (2026): 29 Cited Sources, Zero From the Top 10

Google says there's no special trick to rank in AI Overviews: be indexed and eligible for a snippet. But when I pulled three buyer questions on November 18, 2026, none of the 29 pages the AI Overviews cited were the top-10 links under them. Here's what the cited pages had in common, and what that means for your site.

5 min

GEO for Law Firms (2026): What ChatGPT Actually Uses to Pick a Lawyer

GEO for law firms means getting ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI answers to name your firm when someone asks for a lawyer. I ran two real client questions through ChatGPT: every recommended firm came from its Google Business Profile and Avvo listings, and the website only supplied the reason to call. Here's what to fix first.

5 min
Justin McKelvey, Austin, TX

Written by

Justin McKelvey

I spent 12 years running snowboard and mountain-bike shops in Colorado, then taught myself to code. Since then: 50+ products shipped, Head of Product at a national sports platform, CTO at an AI startup. Now I put AI to work in real businesses in Austin, TX and remote, and write down what actually works.

Work with me

Want more help? Get your free AI visibility report · Book a strategy call

The AI Visibility Starter: the DIY kit for getting recommended by ChatGPT.

Get started →